Not just another WordPress weblog
Digital Economy Bill: A Response From Nick Raynsford MP
On January 27th 2010, I wrote to Nick Raynsford, MP for Greenwich and Woolwich, asking him how he felt about the Digital Economy Bill. When I finally got a response yesterday, dated 17th March 2010, he told me that he hadn’t been able to reply partly due to not receiving a response from Peter Mandelson about my concerns, and partly because with the Bill having not been discussed by the House of Commons yet, he had not been able to scrutinise it properly — but not to worry because the upcoming General Election and Budget Report would take priority over the Bill meaning that it probably wouldn’t be passed.
I’ve responded to Mr Raynsford, explaining to him that:
- I don’t buy his claim that he didn’t reply to my letter for over six weeks because he was waiting for a reply, because my original question was how he personally felt about the Bill. I didn’t want a response from Peter Mandelson, because I know how he feels already: if he didn’t support the proposals, he surely would not have submitted them in the first place.
- I also don’t buy his claim that he couldn’t scrutinise the Bill properly: I have been perfectly able to do so myself online for many months, and I have been paying attention to the Lords debates on the subject to find out which amendments passed and which didn’t; if I can do that, there is no reason for him not to be able to, especially knowing that his constituents have concerns about the Bill.
- As he failed to tell me how he personally felt about the Digital Economy Bill, he did not answer my question.
- That I am even more concerned about the Digital Economy Bill than I was before, because whilst he thinks it will not be passed, many campaigning organisations, and myself, believe that the Government will rush it through without proper debate before Parliament dissolves.
I have asked for another reply in which he answers my question and assures me that he will demand the Digital Economy Bill is properly debated at his earliest convenience. I hope it takes less than 7 weeks this time.
| This entry was posted by tajasel on March 20, 2010 at 16:03, and is filed under Digital Rights. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
about 5 months ago
This seems quite a typical response to some peoples questions regarding the Digital Economy Bill. I say some, as a few have received replies quite quickly that have provided some insight. Yet others have been in the same boat as yourself, waiting weeks and/or just getting a reply that shrugs off questions.
I have wrote to my MP twice now and have yet to receive a reply. I didn’t write to him (Stuart Bell MP) nearly 7 weeks ago but I am not holding out any hope on even getting a reply.
It just seems typical that a lot of politicians are just shrugging off all these questions and letters. But what frightens me is the fact that there are MP’s that don’t feel like they have an opinion or cannot give one and have to speak to Lord Mandelson before they can give you an answer. And that answer is more than like a re-iteration of Mandelson’s opinions which you (and the rest of us) clearly do not want.
Hopefully your reply to him will get some answers… don’t hold your breath though.
about 5 months ago
Labour tend to write to Mandelson to ask what they should say; the Tories and Lib Dems, at least, forward on complaints, and many of the latter two write back to say “yes, we’re concerned too” – although the Tories are still for #3strikes anyway. The Liberal Democrats, thankfully, are against it, as are the Greens – it’s unfortunate that they have such a minority.
If I don’t received a speedy reply this time (i.e., within two weeks, the timeframe that MPs are expected to respond within) I will take the same approach as this time – one further letter a week until I receive a response.
Don’t give up on receiving a reply from your MP; politicians are obliged to respond to their constituents properly. I’m not sure, off the top of my head, who you’d complain to, but you should do so if you can find out. (Ask MySociety, perhaps.)
(I see a lot of letters to/from MPs in my work, as you might have guessed.)